Behdad

Bazaar Pay: Payment as a Service (PaaS)

Tackled BazaarPay's Direct Debit adoption challenge through deep user research, identifying key trust barriers and usability issues to transform a 5% conversion rate service.

Company
Cafe Bazaar
Role
Senior Product Designer
Platform
WebsitePWA
Date
2023
Case study image

The Core: Payment Integration

Service Overview:

  • Third-party payment solution
  • Cross-platform compatibility
  • Multiple payment methods:
    • Digital wallet
    • Direct debit
  • Responsive UI components:
    • Pop-up interface
    • Mobile bottomsheet
  • Seamless merchant integration

Evolution: Store to Universal

The BazaarPay Story: What began as a simple payment solution for Cafe Bazaar's app store transformed into a comprehensive payment service powering transactions across Iran's digital economy. This evolution unfolded in strategic phases, each expanding the platform's capabilities and reach.

Phase 1: App Store Origins The Initial Challenge:

  • Users leaving games/apps for bank payments
  • Disrupted user experience
  • Complex payment flows

Solution Delivered:

  • Integrated payment system
  • Seamless in-app purchases
  • Retained user engagement

Phase 2: Wallet Innovation Key Development:

  • Introduction of digital wallet
  • One-click payment capability
  • Simplified top-up process

User Benefits:

  • No more app switching
  • Faster transactions
  • Reduced friction
  • Enhanced gaming experience

Phase 3: Market Expansion Strategic Growth:

  • Direct debit introduction
  • Merchant network development
  • Universal payment solution

Enhancement Features:

  • One-click card payments
  • Merchant integration tools
  • Cross-platform compatibility

Project Status at My Entry: When I joined the team:

  • Core system established
  • Growing merchant adoption
  • Proven market success
  • New challenges emerging
  • Design optimization needed

Breaking Barriers

Key Challenges Found:

  1. User Understanding Gap
  • Low direct debit success activation rates
  • Unclear differentiation from other payment methods
  • Value proposition not effectively communicated
  1. Trust Barriers
  • Hesitation in sharing bank card details
  • Security concerns
  • Lack of confidence in the system
  1. Policy Clarity Issues
  • Unclear rules and regulations
  • Insufficient policy communication
  • Limited understanding of direct debit mechanics

Our Research Revealed:

  • Users didn't grasp unique benefits
  • Security concerns overshadowed convenience
  • Policy complexity created hesitation
  • Value proposition failed to resonate

The fundamental issue was clear: despite direct debit's potential for payment simplification, users neither understood its benefits nor trusted its security measures enough to activate it.

Data Speaks: Activation Issues

The Numbers Story: Critical metrics revealed significant adoption challenges:

  • Only 5% user conversion in activation flow
  • 11% overall activation success rate
  • Direct impact on revenue potential

Research Methodology:

  1. Quantitative Analysis:
  • Collaboration with data science team
  • Conversion funnel analysis
  • Drop-off point identification
  • Success rate tracking
  1. Qualitative Research: Phone Interviews:
  • Direct user feedback
  • Pain point identification
  • Trust barrier exploration
  • User expectation mapping

Heuristic Evaluation:

  • UX principle alignment
  • Flow optimization opportunities
  • Interface improvement areas
  • Usability gap analysis

Project Goals:

  • Increase activation conversion rates
  • Improve overall success metrics
  • Boost revenue through simplified payments
  • Enhance user trust and understanding
Case study image

Voice of Users

Through 130 phone interviews with non-converted users, we utilized Affinity diagramming to identify four critical barriers to direct debit adoption:

  1. Trust and Security Concerns
    • Hesitation to share bank account access
    • Feasr of unauthorized future transactions
    • Privacy concerns about banking details
  2. Innovation Resistance
    • Unfamiliarity with direct debit concept
    • Unclear functionality and process
    • Uncertainty about payment mechanics
  3. Payment Limit Anxiety
    • Concerns about partial payments
    • Transaction amount limitations
    • Unclear maximum payment thresholds
  4. Technical Reliability
    • Gateway downtime experiences
    • System reliability concerns
    • Technical failure frustrations

Research Methodology:

  • 130 phone interviews
  • Focus on non-converted users
  • Affinity diagram analysis
  • Pattern identification

This comprehensive user research revealed that success hinged not just on technical functionality, but on addressing fundamental user concerns about security, understanding, and reliability.

Case study image
Case study image

Heuristic Evaluation: UX Analysis

Conducted a systematic evaluation of the direct debit activation flow using Nielsen's 10 heuristic principles. Please share the specific findings from this evaluation so we can explore how they complemented your user interview insights.

Case study image

User Persona: Research to Representation

Based on our comprehensive research findings and validated assumptions, I developed user personas to capture the essence of our direct debit users.

Research-Based Persona Creation:

  • Interview insights integration
  • Behavioral pattern analysis
  • Pain point documentation
  • User motivation mapping

Would you like to share the specific personas you created? I can help document:

  • Key characteristics
  • Main concerns and needs
  • Behavioral patterns
  • Goals and motivations
  • Pain points and fears
Case study image

Journey Mapping: User Experience Flow

Created comprehensive journey map tracking user progression through direct debit activation:

Stages Mapped:

  • Awareness & Discovery
  • Initial Interaction
  • Service Registration
  • First Usage
  • Ongoing Engagement

Key Elements Tracked:

  • User Actions
  • Thoughts & Feelings
  • Pain Points & Gains
  • Touchpoints
  • Channels Used
  • Support Needs

Emotional Journey:

  • Confidence levels
  • Trust building moments
  • Frustration points
  • Success celebrations
Case study image

Design in Action: Key Interface Examples

Desktop

Case study image
Case study image
Case study image
Case study image
Case study image

Mobile

Case study image
Case study image
Case study image
Case study image
Case study image
Case study image
Case study image
Case study image
Case study image
Case study image
Case study image
Case study image

Found this helpful?

More case studies